Derivative Benefits, Risks, and Issuer and Investor Uses

Derivatives

Investor Use of Derivatives

Learning Outcome Statement:

compare the use of derivatives among issuers and investors

Summary:

This LOS explores the different ways in which issuers and investors utilize derivatives. Issuers primarily use derivatives to hedge against market risks related to their business operations and financing activities. In contrast, investors leverage derivatives for strategies such as replicating cash market strategies, hedging against adverse movements, and modifying or adding exposures to achieve specific investment goals. The flexibility and lower capital requirements of derivatives make them attractive for investors aiming to manage risks or enhance returns.

Key Concepts:

Hedge Accounting

Hedge accounting is a method that allows an issuer to offset the effects of a hedging instrument against a hedged item on the financial statements, thereby reducing volatility.

Types of Hedges

There are several types of hedges including fair value hedges, cash flow hedges, and net investment hedges, each serving different purposes such as offsetting fair value fluctuations, variable cash flows, and foreign exchange risks respectively.

Investor Use of Derivatives

Investors use derivatives to replicate market strategies, hedge against risks, and adjust exposure to various assets. They often prefer derivatives for their liquidity, lower capital requirements, and the ability to take short positions or modify exposures.

Forward Commitments and Contingent Claims

Investors use forward commitments like futures and forwards to gain exposure to asset prices without immediate cash outlay or delivery. Contingent claims like options allow investors to benefit from movements in asset prices for a premium.

Issuer Use of Derivatives

Learning Outcome Statement:

compare the use of derivatives among issuers and investors

Summary:

This LOS explores how issuers and investors utilize derivatives differently based on their specific needs and objectives. Issuers primarily use derivatives to hedge against risks associated with their commercial operations and financial activities, while investors use derivatives for hedging, replicating cash market strategies, or modifying exposures. The content also delves into the types of hedge accounting treatments and the specific risks associated with derivative markets.

Key Concepts:

Counterparty Credit Risk

The seller of a call option faces no counterparty credit risk once the premium is received, as their obligation is to potentially deliver the underlying asset if the option is exercised, not to make further payments.

Derivative Market Risks

Includes liquidity risk (timing differences in cash flows), basis risk (unexpected divergence in value between derivative and underlying), and systemic risk (market stress due to excessive risk-taking and leverage).

Hedge Accounting

Allows issuers to align the recognition of gains and losses on derivatives with the hedged item on the balance sheet, reducing volatility in financial statements. Types of hedges include cash flow hedges, fair value hedges, and net investment hedges.

FX Forward Contract

Used by issuers like Montau AG to hedge against foreign exchange risk, locking in an exchange rate for future transactions, thus stabilizing profit margins against currency fluctuations.

Formulas:

FX Forward Contract Calculation

EUR_{\text{proceeds}} = \frac{KRW_{\text{amount}}}{F_0(T)}

This formula calculates the Euros received when a predetermined amount of Korean Won is exchanged at the forward rate agreed upon in the FX forward contract.

Variables:

$EUR_{\text{proceeds}}$ :: Amount in Euros received from the contract
$KRW_{\text{amount}}$ :: Amount in Korean Won to be converted
$F_0(T)$ :: Agreed upon forward exchange rate

Units: currency

Derivative Risks

Learning Outcome Statement:

describe benefits and risks of derivative instruments

Summary:

Derivative instruments offer various benefits and risks, including operational advantages, risk transfer, and price discovery. They provide mechanisms for efficient risk allocation, hedging, and increased market efficiency but also introduce complexities and potential risks such as high leverage, liquidity risk, counterparty credit risk, and systemic risks.

Key Concepts:

Operational Advantages

Derivatives provide operational advantages by requiring lower initial cash outlays compared to similar cash market positions, thus offering high implicit leverage.

Risk Transfer

Derivatives allow for the transfer of risk by enabling market participants to buy or sell derivative contracts to hedge against potential timing mismatches between economic decisions and transaction capabilities.

Price Discovery

Derivatives assist in the price discovery process by providing additional market information, such as futures prices, which can indicate market sentiment before trading begins.

Implicit Leverage

Implicit leverage in derivatives refers to the exposure gained relative to the initial cash outlay, which can significantly magnify both gains and losses.

Liquidity Risk

Liquidity risk in derivatives arises from mismatches in cash flow timing between derivative contracts and the underlying transactions, potentially leading to issues like inability to meet margin calls.

Counterparty Credit Risk

This risk involves the possibility that the counterparty to a derivative may default on their obligations, which varies by derivative type and market.

Systemic Risk

Systemic risk refers to the potential for disruptions in the financial system caused by interconnectedness and the aggregate use of derivatives.

Basis Risk

Basis risk occurs when there is a divergence between the expected value of a derivative and the actual market value of the underlying asset, often due to differences in reference rates or indices.

Formulas:

Implicit Leverage Calculation

\text{Implicit Leverage} = \frac{\text{Change in Value}}{\text{Initial Cash Outlay}}

This formula calculates the percentage change in value relative to the initial investment, illustrating the leverage effect in derivatives.

Variables:

$Change in Value$ :: The difference in value of the asset from the initial purchase to a later valuation
$Initial Cash Outlay$ :: The initial amount of money paid or deposited to enter into the transaction

Units: percentage

Derivative Benefits

Learning Outcome Statement:

describe benefits and risks of derivative instruments

Summary:

Derivative instruments offer significant benefits such as risk management, operational advantages, and price discovery. These instruments allow users to manage timing differences between economic decisions and market actions without trading the underlying asset directly. They also provide operational efficiencies by reducing transaction costs and the need for physical handling in commodity markets. Additionally, derivatives play a crucial role in price discovery by providing information about future market expectations.

Key Concepts:

Price Discovery

Derivatives help in predicting future market trends and prices, which is crucial for planning and strategy. For example, equity index futures provide early signals about the likely opening market directions.

Operational Advantages

Derivatives reduce the need for physical handling of commodities, lower transaction costs, and require less upfront capital compared to spot markets, making them operationally efficient.

Risk Management

Derivatives allow for the transfer and management of risk without requiring the actual trading of the underlying asset. This is particularly useful in hedging against price fluctuations or unfavorable movements in currency exchange rates.

Market Efficiency

Derivatives contribute to market efficiency by allowing for quicker adjustments to mispricing and providing platforms for easier execution of complex financial strategies.

Formulas:

FX Forward Payoff

F_0(T) = \text{FX forward profit}

This formula represents the fixed exchange rate agreed upon in an FX forward contract, used to hedge against FX rate fluctuations over the contract period.

Variables:

$F_0(T)$ :: Fixed exchange rate agreed upon at the initiation of the contract for settlement at time T

Units: Currency per unit of foreign currency

Previous Module

Next Module

On this page