Introduction to Financial Statement Modeling

Financial Statement Analysis

Building a Financial Statement Model

Learning Outcome Statement:

demonstrate the development of a sales-based pro forma company model

Summary:

This LOS focuses on demonstrating the development of a sales-based pro forma company model using the example of Rémy Cointreau Group. It covers the construction of pro forma income statements, statements of cash flows, and balance sheets, utilizing historical data and forecasts based on various financial metrics and market conditions.

Key Concepts:

Revenue Forecast

Revenue forecasting involves analyzing historical trends in volume, price, and foreign currency impacts, and adjusting for expected deviations. It includes organic growth from volume and price/mix changes, and considers external factors like forex impacts.

COGS and Gross Margin

Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) is projected based on historical gross margins and expected changes in revenue composition. The forecast includes assumptions about price/mix impacts and volume growth influencing the gross margin.

Operating Expenses

Operating expenses are broken down into distribution costs and administrative expenses, each forecasted as a percentage of revenue. These forecasts consider historical trends and expected changes in the business environment.

Non-Operating Items

Non-operating items include interest expenses, income taxes, and shares outstanding. These are forecasted based on debt positions, statutory tax rates, and historical share data.

Pro Forma Statements

Pro forma financial statements are constructed to provide a forward-looking view of the company's financial position, incorporating forecasts of income statements, cash flows, and balance sheets.

Capital Investments and Depreciation

Forecasts for capital expenditures and depreciation are based on historical percentages of sales and fixed assets, respectively. These forecasts consider the company's investment strategy and asset base growth.

Working Capital

Working capital forecasts involve projecting inventory, accounts receivable, and accounts payable based on days outstanding calculations and expected sales and COGS.

Valuation Model Inputs

Inputs for valuation models, such as DCF, are derived from the forecasted financial statements. These include EBIT, taxes, depreciation, changes in working capital, and capital expenditures.

Formulas:

Organic Revenue Growth

Organic Revenue Growth=[(1+Volume Growth)×(1+Price/Mix)]1\text{Organic Revenue Growth} = [(1 + \text{Volume Growth}) \times (1 + \text{Price/Mix})] - 1

This formula calculates the total organic revenue growth, combining effects from both volume increases and adjustments in pricing or product mix.

Variables:
VolumeGrowthVolume Growth:
Percentage increase in product volume sold
Price/MixPrice/Mix:
Percentage change in revenue from price changes and product mix
Units: percentage

Free Cash Flow to the Firm

\text{FCFF} = \text{EBIT} \times (1 - \text{Tax Rate}) + \text{D&A} - \text{Change in Working Capital} - \text{Capital Expenditures}

This formula calculates the free cash flow available to the firm, an important metric for valuation and financial health assessment.

Variables:
EBITEBIT:
Earnings before interest and taxes
TaxRateTax Rate:
Applicable corporate tax rate
D&A:
Depreciation and amortization
ChangeinWorkingCapitalChange in Working Capital:
Net change in working capital
CapitalExpendituresCapital Expenditures:
Investments in capital assets
Units: euro millions

Behavioral Finance and Analyst Forecasts

Learning Outcome Statement:

explain how behavioral factors affect analyst forecasts and recommend remedial actions for analyst biases

Summary:

This LOS discusses the impact of behavioral biases on financial analysts' forecasts and suggests methods to mitigate these biases. It identifies five key biases: overconfidence, illusion of control, conservatism, representativeness, and confirmation bias. Each bias is explained with its implications on forecasting accuracy and potential remedies to improve forecast reliability and objectivity.

Key Concepts:

Overconfidence in Forecasting

Overconfidence bias occurs when analysts have unwarranted faith in their forecasting abilities, often leading to narrower confidence intervals and higher error rates. Remedies include recording and reviewing forecasts, widening confidence intervals, and conducting scenario analysis.

Illusion of Control

This bias leads analysts to overestimate their ability to control events and to create overly complex models that do not necessarily improve forecasting accuracy. Mitigation strategies include simplifying models and focusing only on essential and reliable data sources.

Conservatism Bias

Conservatism bias involves analysts' reluctance to update their forecasts in light of new, conflicting information. This can be mitigated by regular reviews of forecasts and models, and by maintaining flexible models that allow for easy adjustment of assumptions.

Representativeness Bias

This bias occurs when analysts classify new information based on past experiences or familiar classifications, which may lead to incorrect conclusions. Analysts can counter this by considering both the 'outside view' (industry averages) and 'inside view' (company-specific factors) in their models.

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias is the tendency to search for or interpret information in a way that confirms one's preconceptions, leading to biased decision-making. This can be mitigated by seeking out diverse opinions and considering negative perspectives in the research process.

The Impact of Competitive Factors in Prices and Costs

Learning Outcome Statement:

explain how the competitive position of a company based on a Porter’s five forces analysis affects prices and costs

Summary:

The learning outcome statement focuses on understanding the impact of a company's competitive position, as analyzed through Porter's Five Forces framework, on its pricing and cost structure. The content elaborates on how various competitive factors influence a company's financial outcomes, using the cognac industry and other examples to illustrate these effects.

Key Concepts:

Porter's Five Forces

A framework developed by Michael Porter that helps analyze the competitive forces within an industry that affect its profitability. These forces include the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers, the threat of new entrants, the threat of substitutes, and industry rivalry.

Impact on Prices and Costs

The competitive structure of an industry, as determined by Porter's Five Forces, influences a company's ability to set prices and control costs. For instance, high bargaining power of buyers can suppress prices, while intense rivalry might increase promotional costs.

Cognac Industry Analysis

The cognac industry is characterized by limited supply and growing demand, with significant control by a few major players. This structure allows these companies to maintain high prices and profitability despite various competitive pressures.

Modeling Inflation and Deflation

Learning Outcome Statement:

explain how to forecast industry and company sales and costs when they are subject to price inflation or deflation

Summary:

The content discusses the impact of inflation and deflation on forecasting sales and costs for industries and companies. It highlights how different factors such as industry structure, competitive positioning, and price elasticity affect the ability to pass on cost increases to consumers and how these factors influence revenue and cost projections under varying inflationary or deflationary conditions.

Key Concepts:

Sales Projections with Inflation and Deflation

Sales projections in inflationary conditions depend on the industry's ability to pass increased input costs onto consumers. Factors like industry structure, competitive advantage, and price elasticity of demand play crucial roles. For instance, oligopolistic markets with few competitors might manage to raise prices in line with inflation more easily than highly competitive markets.

Cost Projections with Inflation and Deflation

Cost projections must consider the potential for input price increases or decreases and the company's ability to mitigate these through strategies such as long-term contracts, hedging, or operational efficiencies. The impact of inflation or deflation on costs also depends on the competitive environment and the company's flexibility in managing input costs.

Price Elasticity of Demand

This is a measure of the responsiveness of the quantity demanded of a good to a change in its price. High elasticity means consumers are sensitive to price changes, which can complicate decisions about passing on input cost increases in inflationary periods.

Formulas:

Revenue Growth Calculation

Rnew=Rold×(1+price increase)×(1+volume growth)1R_{new} = R_{old} \times (1 + \text{price increase}) \times (1 + \text{volume growth}) - 1

This formula calculates the new revenue by adjusting the old revenue for both price increases and volume growth.

Variables:
RnewR_{new}:
New revenue
RoldR_{old}:
Old revenue
Units: percentage

COGS Adjustment for Inflation

Cnew=Cold×(1+inflation rate)C_{new} = C_{old} \times (1 + \text{inflation rate})

This formula adjusts the old cost of goods sold for inflation to estimate the new cost of goods sold.

Variables:
CnewC_{new}:
New cost of goods sold
ColdC_{old}:
Old cost of goods sold
Units: currency

The Forecast Horizon and Long-Term Forecasting

Learning Outcome Statement:

Explain considerations in the choice of an explicit forecast horizon and an analyst’s choices in developing projections beyond the short-term forecast horizon

Summary:

The choice of a forecast horizon is influenced by factors such as investment strategy, industry cyclicality, company-specific factors, and employer preferences. Long-term forecasting allows for adjustments for temporary factors and provides a more accurate representation of normalized earnings potential. Key considerations include the method of revenue projection, the calculation of terminal value, and the impact of economic disruptions, regulation, and technology.

Key Concepts:

Forecast Horizon

The forecast horizon is the time period over which an analyst projects the financial performance of a company. The length of this period can be influenced by the investment strategy, industry cyclicality, and specific company events such as mergers or acquisitions.

Normalized Earnings

Normalized earnings refer to the expected level of earnings a company would achieve in a typical business cycle, absent any unusual or temporary factors. This concept is crucial for long-term forecasting as it provides a more stable basis for projections.

Revenue Projection

Revenue projection is the starting point of long-term financial forecasting. Methods such as growth relative to GDP and market share analysis are used to estimate future revenues.

Terminal Value

Terminal value is an estimate of a company's value at the end of the explicit forecast period and is a critical component of models like the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model. It captures the going-concern value of the company and is influenced by long-term growth rates and economic conditions.

Economic Disruptions

Sudden economic events like financial crises or pandemics can significantly impact a company's financial performance and should be considered when making long-term forecasts.

Regulation and Technology

Changes in regulation and technological advancements can serve as inflection points that significantly alter a company's growth trajectory and competitive position, affecting long-term forecasts.