Industry and Competitive Analysis

Equity

Uses of Industry Analysis

Learning Outcome Statement:

describe the purposes of, and steps involved in, industry and competitive analysis

Summary:

Industry and competitive analysis is crucial for understanding the drivers of an industry's size, profitability, and market shares, as well as evaluating a company's competitive positioning within its industry. This analysis helps in forecasting, identifying investment opportunities, and formulating competitive strategies.

Key Concepts:

Why Analyze an Industry?

Analyzing an industry helps understand common opportunities and risks that companies within the same industry face due to similar business models and market conditions. Industry analysis also helps in understanding the long-term sustainability of economic profits influenced by industry structure and competitive forces.

Improve Forecasts

Industry analysis enhances the accuracy of forecasts by providing insights into competitive forces and historical data on competitive actions and strategies. This broader perspective helps analysts predict future market behaviors more accurately.

Identify Investment Opportunities

Through industry analysis, analysts can identify attractive investment opportunities by comparing the strengths and weaknesses of companies within the same industry. This can lead to diversified investment strategies that mitigate company-specific risks.

Industry and Competitive Analysis Steps

The steps involved in industry and competitive analysis include defining the industry, conducting an industry survey, analyzing industry structure through models like Porter's Five Forces, assessing external influences using PESTLE analysis, and evaluating a company's competitive strategy and positioning.

Industry Classification

Learning Outcome Statement:

describe industry classification methods and compare methods by which companies can be grouped

Summary:

Industry classification involves grouping companies based on similar products or services they offer, which is crucial for analysis in investment management. Third-party industry classification schemes like GICS, ICB, and TRBC provide structured taxonomies to categorize companies globally. However, these schemes have limitations such as handling multi-industry companies and geographical considerations. Alternative methods for grouping companies include geographic classification, sensitivity to the business cycle, statistical similarities, and ESG characteristics.

Key Concepts:

Third-Party Industry Classification Schemes

Schemes like GICS, ICB, and TRBC are used to categorize companies globally into hierarchical structures based on the similarity of the products or services they sell. These are updated regularly to accommodate new companies and changing business models.

Limitations of Third-Party Industry Classification Schemes

These schemes may not accurately reflect the diversity within industries, especially for companies that operate across multiple industries or have diverse product lines. They also may not account well for geographical differences and changes over time can affect comparability.

Alternative Methods of Grouping Companies

Besides the standard industry classification, companies can also be grouped by geography, sensitivity to the business cycle, statistical similarities in financial metrics, or ESG characteristics. These methods can provide different insights compared to traditional industry classifications.

Industry Survey

Learning Outcome Statement:

determine an industry’s size, growth characteristics, profitability, and market share trends

Summary:

An industry survey involves estimating the size of an industry, calculating its historical growth rate, evaluating the character of that growth, measuring its profitability, and identifying major industry players and market share trends. This comprehensive analysis provides a foundation for further industry evaluation and helps analysts understand key issues and opportunities within the industry.

Key Concepts:

Industry Size and Historical Growth Rate

Industry size is measured by total annual sales, which may not include all sales of each industry constituent. Historical growth rates can be calculated year-over-year or as a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR), considering contributions from volume and price/mix drivers.

Characterizing Industry Growth

The historical growth pattern of an industry can be characterized by its growth rate magnitude and sensitivity to the business cycle. Growth industries have idiosyncratic drivers separate from broader economic growth, while mature industries have growth rates in line with or declining relative to broader economic activity.

Industry Profitability Measures

The best measure of industry profitability is the distribution of returns on invested capital over time. Profitability can also be assessed through the profitability of publicly traded companies within the industry, assuming similar profitability for private competitors.

Formulas:

Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI)

HHI=i=1si2HHI = \sum_{i=1}^{\infty} s_i^2

The HHI is used to measure the concentration of market power within an industry. It is calculated as the sum of the squares of the market shares of all competitors in the industry. Higher values indicate higher concentration and less competition.

Variables:
sis_i:
market share of market participant i stated as a whole number (e.g., 50% share = 50, not 0.50)
Units: unitless (index)

Industry Structure and External Influences

Learning Outcome Statement:

analyze an industry’s structure and external influences using Porter’s Five Forces and PESTLE frameworks

Summary:

This LOS covers the analysis of industry structure and external influences through Porter's Five Forces and PESTLE frameworks. It emphasizes understanding the competitive dynamics within an industry, including the threat of new entrants, bargaining power of customers and suppliers, threat of substitutes, and rivalry among existing competitors. Additionally, it explores external factors affecting industry growth such as political, economic, social, technological, legal, and environmental influences.

Key Concepts:

Porter's Five Forces

A framework used to analyze the competitive forces within an industry that affect its profitability. These forces include the bargaining power of suppliers and customers, the threat of new entrants and substitutes, and the intensity of rivalry among existing competitors.

PESTLE Analysis

A strategic tool used to identify and analyze the external macro-environmental factors that might impact an industry. These factors include Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, and Environmental influences.

Threat of New Entrants

Refers to the potential for new competitors to enter the industry, which can affect the market share of existing companies. Barriers to entry like economies of scale, brand loyalty, and regulatory policies can influence this threat.

Bargaining Power of Customers

Describes the influence customers have on an industry. High bargaining power allows customers to demand lower prices or higher quality.

Bargaining Power of Suppliers

Indicates how much power suppliers have to drive up the prices of inputs. This power is higher when there are fewer substitutes for the input or when switching suppliers is costly.

Threat of Substitutes

The threat that alternative products or services may offer similar or better benefits to consumers, potentially capturing the market share of existing companies in the industry.

Rivalry Among Existing Competitors

The intensity of competition among existing firms in the industry. High rivalry pressures prices and impacts the profitability of all firms involved.

Political Influences

Include government policies, regulatory changes, and political stability that can affect an industry’s operations and profitability.

Economic Influences

Factors such as GDP growth, inflation, and economic cycles that can influence consumer spending and industry performance.

Social Influences

Cultural trends, demographic changes, and shifts in consumer behavior that can impact industry demand and market dynamics.

Technological Influences

Advancements in technology that can create new products, improve processes, or render existing products obsolete.

Environmental Influences

Environmental factors and sustainability issues that can impact industry operations, such as regulations on emissions and waste management.

Competitive Positioning

Learning Outcome Statement:

evaluate the competitive strategy and position of a company

Summary:

Competitive positioning involves assessing a company's strategy to determine if it effectively defends against industry forces, aligns with external influences, and is executable with available resources. Key strategies include cost leadership, differentiation, and focus, each defending against specific threats and carrying unique risks.

Key Concepts:

Intentional vs Unintentional Strategy

An intentional strategy is a deliberate plan involving company-wide planning and feedback, while an unintentional strategy arises from disparate actions within a company, often leading to suboptimal outcomes.

Generic Competitive Strategies

Three primary strategies identified by Michael Porter include cost leadership (focusing on efficiency and scale), differentiation (offering unique products or services), and focus (targeting specific market segments).

Evaluation Dimensions

A competitive strategy should be evaluated based on its defense against industry forces, alignment with external PESTLE factors, and the company's capability to execute the strategy.

Risks Associated with Strategies

Each strategy carries specific risks such as cost inflation for cost leaders, imitation for differentiation, and larger competitors for focus strategies.